Here is my point by point first look / brief review.
Let’s customize it.
– Import (IE/Firefox both): Check.
– Default browser: Hmm, let’s wait for you to prove you mettle.
– Shortcuts: Well, good enough. Google has made sure you won’t forget Chrome easily.
Yay! The first warning. Is it me or 3 stacked windows look like clutter?
Anyway, I’ll close Firefox.
Well that was quick. Now, let’s look at what we have here. (Click on image for detailed screenshot)
It doesn’t fit by default to my widescreen. Anyway, the UI looks really smooth and polished. But it looks very non-windows like. So already, Firefox 3 is ahead in the sense that it gives you the look and feel of the base Operating System 🙂
Let’s zoom in to the features one by one:
Opera wannabe. Not bad, although I’ve always preferred a blank homepage
Now this looks good (and useful). Search history and recent bookmarks. I hope they are customizable.
What! No auto-complete in search. Oh come’ on Google.
OmniBox (Address Bar): I am expecting improvements over Firefox’s awesome bar.
What the hell is it trying to do here? I think it’s directly searching my name on Google.
Let’s see what Firefox does:
Well, this is much better. It lists my recently visited websites with my name as header. Since Google has this history information too, it should have performed better.
This also means that there is no separate Search Bar. Sucks!
In another test Google Chrome refused to list Google Chrome homepage even though it was opened in the next tab. I agree that separate tabs have separate processes but whatever happened to Inter-process Communication?
So as of now, Firefox’s Awesome Bar is better than the OmniBox. For rest of the look and feel I like Chrome but mainly because the Windows XP UI is pretty old and boring.
Oh, History is a tab not a dropdown. I hate this. Why would I navigate to another tab to look into the History ?
Otherwise, it looks good and search works perfectly. Just like Google Desktop Search. Firefox does the job as well. It’s more or less a tie, except for those like me who hate the separate tab for History.
Well, this is good. A dropdown as it should be.
But wait, I can’t click the middle mouse button to open all links in a folder. Heck, there seems to be no way to do this. Adding a bookmark is exactly same as Firefox 3. I can’t find any Bookmarks manager though, strange! The editing is really trivial, no options at all. But it isn’t bad.
Overall, It seems Firefox wins again, marginally this time though.
I have high aspirations here. I just hate how browsers handle downloads.
Aargh! struggling again to reach Google Desktop’s download page. It’s final. I hate OmniBox.
Anyway, download starts with a cute animation and a new download bar pops up in bottom. Pretty nice.
Oh, I can’t right click the download box, I have to explicitly click on the arrow next to it. No problem, there you go.
I see no Pause button. No problem again. I’ll open the downloads tab (linked on the right of the Download bar).
Here’s the Downloads tab. It looks really good. Better than the Firefox popup.
This Downloads UI is not really polished. No multiple select possible. No “delete all downloaded/canceled” options. And the right click is not natural. Makes me realize that this is a web-app not an actual application. Oh yes, no clean download progress bar too!
Also, I can’t resume canceled downloads. So cancel is like the never-press-me button.
Anyhow, the Downloads tab looks promising. I’m sure they can fix these small issues in later releases.
Search in page:
Works exactly like Safari. I love it. I always wanted Firefox to have this.
Doesn’t exist. Just a small dropdown on right with common options. Learnt from IE 7 and improved tremendously. I love this too.
I closed a full window with 12 tabs and it didn’t warn or anything. There was no restore option when I opened up again.
But when a Chrome window crashes, it asks you to Restore from the backup it has made. Just as expected. Firefox wins by a little margin.
I love the status bar that appears only when required. The more screen estate, the better. Especially for widescreen displays.
Now this sure is a cool new feature. Open a new Incognito window and browser won’t any history for this particular window. So now you don’t need to clear the you-know-what history every time before someone uses your computer.
The option screen is very similar to Firefox 3, except some re-arrangements. I can see that they’ve done this to make it easier for the non-technical crowd. It works well too.
But the geeky crowd will find this new arrangement clumsy.
This is something which everyone hates about Firefox. The extreme memory footprint. And Google Chrome really trumps Firefox in this category. As expected from the new architecture, the sluggishness is non-existent. With as many as 10 tabs (including 3 long flickr pages full of images) Chrome works smooth. The only noticeable lag is in rendering, which seems to become slower as we open more tabs. This is expected due to the multiple processes running in parallel and is pretty reasonable.
Also, either I am too sleepy or I can actually see the rendering process switching contexts between tabs. Please confirm if you feel that too (Only visible when lots of tabs are open).To top it all, Google Chrome consumes much lesser memory than Firefox with same no. of tabs (with same content) open. In my tests it’s almost 30% lesser with around 10 tabs open.
And yes, it shows multiple process entries for each tab (as expected), so it can be a bit confusing. When, say you want to kill a certain process, but can’t because all processes are called “chrome.exe”.
That covers everything I found interesting about the new Google Chrome. It sure has it’s issues and I won’t be switching from Firefox anytime soon. But all these issues are very fixable. Once Google irons them out, Chrome will undoubtedly jump ahead of the competitors. After all, it is built on an amazing design and foundation.
Without doubt this is Google’s best product announcement since a long time.
Liked this article? Like us on Facebook!
Putting an end to the rumors floating all over the blogosphere for the last few months, Google announced their plan...